You agree to the terms of service below, and the Terms of Use for Substack, the technology provider.

Thorough analysis thrives when people think out loud. To keep the conversation productive, keep these principles in mind:

  • Evidence is the currency: Analysis here is evidence-based and structurally grounded. If you want to dispute a conclusion, bring counter-evidence. The conversation will be better for it.

  • Disagreement vs. Abuse: Disagreement is welcome; abuse is not. The distinction isn’t complicated. Comments designed to be unpleasant rather than constructive will be removed without discussion. Repeat offenders will be removed without ceremony.

  • Zero Tolerance: Misinformation, harassment, and bad-faith arguments have no place here, regardless of the target.

The baseline for participation is good faith. Everything else follows from there.